Health & Safety

New Health and Safety Sentencing Guidelines

New sentencing guidelines for health & safety offences came into force from the beginning of February 2016. They are intended to increase the level of fines, particularly for larger organisations. However, unintended consequences of the way punishments are now calculated mean that courts will hand out much larger fines than previously expected and send many more directors, managers and employees to jail for breaching health & safety laws.

How will the new guidelines work?

For most health and safety offences, the law now offers unlimited fines, leaving it to judges and magistrates to decide how the fine should ‘fit the crime’. To help the Court the Sentencing Council have created the guidelines which are now in force.

Inspection of the sentencing guidelines shows that there are now four significant factors which are going to significantly increase the level of fines. Equally the changes have impacted upon the threshold for imprisonment, meaning that this will be reached very much more easily than it has before.

The sentencing guidelines introduce a structured approach that the court must follow. This involves fitting ‘culpability’, ‘likelihood’ and ‘harm’ factors into a series of predefined tables to reach recommended starting point fines, as well as ranges of fines above and below the starting points. Again with imprisonment of individuals, the tables stipulate ranges of sentences above and below various starting points.

The new guidelines see a significant move from the traditional result based approach (what was the seriousness of the injury) to a risk based approach (how serious was the harm that was risked).

As an example of how this change could impact on suppose someone is walking through a warehouse and an object falls from high racking landing on their foot and damages their toes. Previously such an incident  would be have seen a more lenient approach to prosecution and sentencing than if the same thing had hit someone on the head, killing them.

Under the risk based system, an injury to the foot or toes, is easily in hindsight, seen as having involved a high risk of death or permanent disability and is calculated at a level of fatality.

In reality all non-fatal accidents or incidents relating to health and safety, could have resulted in a more serious outcome and the new guidelines will lead the courts to sentence companies and individuals to a level relating to the more serious outcome.

Alternatively, if the offence exposed didn’t just impact on one person, but exposed a group of individuals to harm, the Court is again directed to punishment at a higher level.

Finally, if someone is actually harmed in an accident or incident, Courts are once again directed to increase the level of punishment.

So What Happens Now

Firstly business owners, board members, senior managers and employees need to understand that complying with health and safety is not a goal, for their business to achieve. It is in fact the bare minimum that the law requires employers to do.  With that in mind, failure to achieve the bare minimum will eventually lead to something going wrong and when it does, the combined effect of the new guidelines will lead to criminal sanctions, starting in the middle of the scale.  While the Courts are allowed some level of discretion, it is not enough to move too far away from the prescribed sentencing tables.

An example of this will be the impact on an individual’s liberty. It will be extremely difficult if not impossible for someone to escape a jail sentence, when convicted, if they were aware of a risk, did nothing and it resulted in several people being exposed to a ‘medium’ likelihood of death or disability.

With the chance of hugely increased fines and the real possibility of imprisonment, it has never been more important to bring the importance of health and safety to the attention of board members and senior managers, along with employees and explain how the law expects them to act to stay out of jail.

For more information about our Health & Safety Services, get in touch with our team at Park City for more information. 

Get in Touch


Schedule A Call

Simply click below to schedule a call with a specialist to discuss your business requirements.

Saul HunnaballSaul Hunnaball
15:44 12 Aug 22
We have worked with Park City for our HR and Health and Safety support for many years now and have always received an excellent service.Carley is our Consultant and she is always so helpful, as are... her colleagues when she is unavailable.I would highly recommend Park more
Lea CuttingLea Cutting
08:31 27 Jul 22
Park City have worked with us for many years, advising and guiding us regarding HR and Health & Safety, along with supplying valuable training.We work with many people in several areas of expertise,... Sara Godfrey, Jennie Galione, Ashley Williams, Sam Parcell, Stephanie Devans, Poppy Hayhoe.They build confidence within our company and are always available with support and advice.They provide a consistent, professional, hands-on service, second to none!Thank you from DH Industries more
Vikki PringleVikki Pringle
11:12 20 Jul 22
The team at Park City offer us the right level of service needed to confidently run a small business. They keep us up to date with UK policy HR requirements, help us manage any staff changes or... issues and policy documents. The team are informed, friendly and remain professional in my more
Tracy MeadTracy Mead
07:12 20 Jul 22
The DS Group have been working with Park City now for a number of years and we have found their HR services to be invaluable. The service received is always to the highest professional standards and... they have assisted our business in becoming more efficient and effective in all HR matters.My consultant Sam Parcell is always on hand to help answering any questions quickly and professionally and she offers vital guidance, advice and support to us.We as a company will continue to use Park City’s services for many years to come and we cannot recommend them enough!Tracy Norton-Mead, Operations Director at the DS more
Katie HerbertKatie Herbert
13:35 07 Jul 22
We have worked with Park City for almost 10 years and have built up a great professional relationship over the years. The team are so friendly and helpful, and nothing is ever too much of an ask for... any of them. Our main HR contact is Carley, who is lovely, and she is very prompt in dealing with any queries we have regarding our 100+ staff. We would highly recommend their services for any local more

Suggested For You…

Google Rating
Based on 37 reviews